Was Nikolai Topor-Stanley’s Knee Injury the Turning Point of the A-League Grand Final?

Published: 07 May 2014

Was Nikolai Topor-Stanley’s Knee Injury the Turning Point of the A-League Grand Final?

The implications of Nikolai’s medial collateral ligament injury and gives us a great over-view of the management of this common football (all codes) injury….

It was half way through the 2nd half in the A-League Grand final match between Western Sydney Wanderers and Brisbane Roar. The Wanderers up 1-0 before Nikolai Topor-Stanley was involved in a tackle that left the medical staff with a big decision – should he return to the field?

Nikolai fell awkwardly, stressing his medial collateral ligament which is located on the inner side of the knee joint. The ligament connects the thigh bone (femur) to the shank (tibia) and prevents the knee collapsing inwards towards the other.

The damage to a ligament is referred to as a sprain and the amount of damage determines the grading of a first, second or third degree sprain:

  • A grade 1 injury involves a small number of ligament fibres, with pain associated but no instability.
  • A grade 2 injury involves a larger amount of ligament fibres, with more intense pain, some instability of the ligament and possible swelling of the knee joint.
  • A grade 3 injury is a complete tear of the ligament. The patient will have to cease activity due to instability of the knee joint.

Treatment will all depend upon the grade of the injury: t
he injury will likely take place through direct contact to the outside side of the knee or via a twisting mechanism whereby the foot is planted into the floor and the pivot occurs away from the affected knee. Furthermore, it is possible to damage the ligament through a more constant minor repeated strain; this type of injury is common in swimmers who are involved in long distance breaststroke.

  • A grade 1 injury would initially require some rest, ice, compression and elevation. The physiotherapist would continue specific manual therapy techniques to resolve any residual muscle spasm involved. It is likely that the patient would need between 1 and 3 weeks before return to sport or physical activity.
  • A grade 2 injury would include a similar treatment plan, with an additional brace to allow for healing of the ligament and preventing further instability. The swelling within the knee is important to reduce immediately to reduce the time required for rehabilitation back to sport or physical activity.
  • A grade 3 injury would involve a similar treatment plan, with a surgical review to distinguish if conservative or surgical treatment would be indicated. When the MCL is completely ruptured, it is likely that surrounding structures within the knee have also been damaged. Conservative treatment would involve prolonged use of the limiting brace and use of crutches for some weeks.

Along side the treatment mentioned, the physiotherapist will develop a personalised home exercise program that will aim at achieving full range of motion and strengthening surrounding muscles in a functional and sports specific manner.

Thankfully for Nikolai Topor-Stanley, he will have many weeks to rehabilitate his injury in the off season and not be pressured to return to sport too soon.